Peter Stewart of Peter Stewart Realty Group: The Investor-Focused Broker Shaping Indianapolis Real Estate

Peter Stewart is a prominent figure in the Indianapolis metro area real estate market, serving Carmel and surrounding communities throughout Greater Indianapolis. With nearly 17 years of experience and a distinctly investor-centric approach, he has built a reputation as a trusted advisor for both first-time homebuyers and seasoned investors. As the founder of Peter Stewart Realty Group at Keller Williams Realty Carmel, Peter guides clients through the complexities of property acquisition and sales with precision and strategic insight. Explore his expertise here.

Peter’s journey into real estate began in Los Angeles, where he transitioned from a career as a payroll accountant for Paramount Pictures. Driven by an entrepreneurial spirit and a desire to overcome professional “ceilings,” he dove headfirst into the industry. This career pivot also unveiled a rich family history in real estate, with his grandfather having served as president of the Board of Realtors in Indianapolis and owning apartment buildings. This deep-seated connection to the business fuels Peter’s approach today. 

An Investor-Focused Niche with Global Reach

Peter specializes in real estate investing, proudly holding the title of top investor-focused broker in the Indianapolis metro area. A staggering 80% of his clientele are investors, with 98% of those being remote investors from around the globe, demonstrating his specialized reach and capability. During his time in Los Angeles, Peter represented a high-profile A-list celebrity in the purchase of a $4.5 million property, an opportunity that came through a trusted referral after he successfully helped the client’s personal assistant purchase her first home. The experience reinforced Peter’s belief that trust, discretion, and results drive long-term success.

High-Volume Experience That Sets Him Apart

What truly distinguishes Peter is his extensive experience and hands-on involvement. He has personally closed over a quarter billion dollars in sales and consistently sells more than 100 properties per year, a remarkable feat for an individual agent, far exceeding the industry average. His career milestones include being named Rookie of the Year at Keller Williams Westwood in Los Angeles in 2009 and currently standing as the number one individual agent at the Keller Williams Realty Carmel office.

Beyond his brokerage success, Peter is a dedicated real estate investor himself, boasting a multi-million dollar portfolio across several states. Since 2011, he has engaged in various investment strategies, including flips, land development, short-term rentals, and long-term rentals, and is currently pursuing an apartment building via a 1031 exchange. This personal investment experience provides Peter with invaluable insights, allowing him to “practice what he preaches” and offer clients a comprehensive understanding of real estate’s investment potential.

Peter’s dedication to his clients and the business is unwavering. He views real estate as a lifestyle, one he has fully immersed himself in for almost two decades. This commitment ensures that every client, whether purchasing a starter home or a multi-million dollar estate, receives meticulous, expert guidance. He emphasizes that real estate is often the most significant investment people make, and his ability to analyze properties from a holistic, investment-driven perspective sets him apart. This approach empowers clients to make informed decisions that extend beyond superficial aesthetics, focusing on long-term value and wealth creation. Peter believes firmly in the transformative power of real estate, echoing the sentiment that more millionaires have been made through property than any other asset class.

A Trusted Partner in a Dynamic Market

For those navigating the dynamic Indianapolis–Carmel real estate market, Peter Stewart offers unmatched experience, investor-level insight, and a proven track record built over nearly two decades. Whether buying a home or building a portfolio, clients benefit from his strategic approach and hands-on expertise. Learn more or connect with Peter here.