When Biotech Is Dirt Cheap and Petco Rallies on Bad News—Something’s Off

Dear Investor,

If you’re confused by the market today, you’re not alone. Petco just rallied after telling investors to expect even worse sales. Biotech stocks are trading like they’ve got fleas, but analysts are suddenly calling them “bargains.” Meanwhile, oil is expected to stay stuck in the mud next year, and futures are slipping on fresh tariff talk and a side of AI skepticism.

This isn’t just a day of odd headlines—it’s a sign of deeper dislocations. Let’s get into it.

Petco Rises on… a Sales Decline?

Petco says revenue is going to fall again this year—but the stock popped anyway. Why? Because apparently, losing less money than expected is now bullish. Welcome to the participation trophy phase of earnings season.

Dig deeper, and it’s clear the rally has more to do with restructuring hype and cost cuts than any actual revenue growth. But the fundamentals haven’t changed: margins are thin, foot traffic is slowing, and consumers are getting choosier with every inflation print. Betting on a turnaround is one thing—but celebrating a weak forecast? That’s a stretch.

🔹 Actionable Takeaway: When bad news rallies stocks, watch out. These are often short-covering traps—not signs of real conviction. Don’t chase moves like this without technical confirmation.

Biotech Stocks: Abandoned and Underpriced?

Biotech’s been wrecked lately. Retail fear, meme-stock fatigue, and low risk appetite have pushed dozens of names to multi-year lows. But here’s the kicker: value is actually emerging—especially in companies with late-stage pipelines and real FDA traction.

Some of these stocks are trading below cash levels or getting scooped up in private deals while the public market sleeps. That doesn’t mean every biotech is a buy—but it does mean the baby has been tossed with the bathwater. If you know how to separate the science from the hype, there’s serious upside hiding in plain sight.

🔹 Actionable Takeaway: Look past the panic. Late-stage biotech names with real catalysts are offering asymmetric setups—if you can stomach the noise and focus on fundamentals.

Citi’s Call: Oil’s Going Nowhere in 2025

Citi now expects oil prices to stay rangebound next year—hovering between $70–$90 as supply normalizes and demand shows no breakout strength. That’s a big shift from last year’s “$100 oil” consensus, and it has ripple effects for everything from inflation to energy stocks.

This kind of forecast gives cover to central banks hoping to avoid new inflation shocks—but it’s also a flashing yellow light for energy investors banking on another breakout. If oil stays tame, high-beta energy names could lag hard. Don’t expect crude to bail out lagging portfolios in 2025.

🔹 Actionable Takeaway: Position for stable—not spiking—energy prices. That means focusing on integrated names with strong cash flow, not chasing momentum in high-volatility producers.

Futures Slip on AI Doubts and Trump Tariff Threats

Stock futures dropped this morning after two familiar spooks resurfaced: AI skepticism and Donald Trump’s tariff rhetoric. Reports that generative AI may be overhyped slammed big tech yesterday, while Trump’s chatter about hitting foreign autos with new tariffs triggered renewed trade jitters.

Together, these headlines are waking up volatility—and reminding traders just how fragile this rally is. When the same narratives that pushed markets higher start reversing, it doesn’t take much to knock things down a peg. Watch tech leadership closely; if it breaks, everything else could follow.

🔹 Actionable Takeaway: Keep a close eye on AI names and large-cap tech. If they roll over, expect broad market pressure. Tariff noise only adds fuel to the pullback.

Where This All Connects

Petco’s pop on a downbeat forecast. Biotech names trading like liabilities when they’re actually assets. Oil losing its inflation bite. And tariffs plus AI fatigue throwing shade on the bull case.

None of these are isolated. They’re all symptoms of a market trying to reprice risk in real time—where headlines swing sentiment and fundamentals are either ignored or misread. That’s when setups get sloppy and reversals hit hard.

So here’s the move: don’t get cute. Stay sharp on positioning, don’t chase fake strength, and be ready to act when real dislocations emerge. Because in a market this fragmented, discipline is the only edge that lasts.

Jim Archer

To your success,

Jim Archer
Chief Breakout Identifier
Wealth Creation Investing