As an eating disorder specialist, I see every day how deeply weight stigma and diet culture shape the way people think about their bodies, health, and even their worth. One of the most pervasive narratives is that losing weight will automatically make you happier, calmer, and more confident. But the reality is much more complex, and, in many cases, the pursuit of weight loss can harm mental health instead of helping it.
Here are five common myths about weight loss and mental health, and what the research actually says.
1. “Losing weight will make me love my body.”
It is easy to believe that if you just reach a certain number on the scale, you will finally feel comfortable in your skin. However, body image isn’t fixed by shrinking your body; it is a relationship with yourself that’s shaped by your thoughts, emotions, and experiences.
Studies show that even after significant weight loss, many people remain dissatisfied with their bodies, and sometimes become more preoccupied with perceived flaws (Polivy & Herman, 2002). When you have been taught that your worth depends on your appearance, no amount of weight loss can undo that underlying shame.
Instead of improving mental health, this myth often keeps people stuck in cycles of self-criticism, anxiety, and social withdrawal. Cultivating body respect and self-compassion is a more sustainable path to peace than chasing an “ideal” body size.
2. “Weight loss will solve my mental health struggles.”
Depression, anxiety, and low self-esteem can feel like they would melt away if you could change your body. Moreover, while it is true that physical health and mental health are connected, there is no evidence that weight loss alone cures psychological pain.
In fact, restrictive dieting and hyper-focus on weight often worsen mental health, increasing preoccupation with food, social isolation, and feelings of failure when weight inevitably fluctuates (Bacon & Aphramor, 2011).
What is more, research shows that weight stigma itself, the experience of being judged, shamed, or treated differently because of your body size, is a major driver of depression, anxiety, and poor self-esteem (Puhl & Suh, 2015).
Healing emotional pain starts with addressing the distress directly, not by trying to control or shrink your body.
3. “I just need more willpower to lose weight and keep it off.”
This myth is one of the most damaging because it turns a biological reality into a moral failing. Dieting triggers powerful physiological and psychological responses designed to keep you alive, including a slowed metabolism, increased hunger hormones, and heightened focus on food.
When people regain weight after dieting, they often blame themselves and feel intense shame, fueling depression and anxiety. Studies show that long-term weight loss is not sustainable for most people, not because they are lazy or lack discipline, but because their bodies are fighting to protect them (Mann et al., 2007).
This constant cycle of self-blame can deeply erode mental health.
4. “Being in a larger body is always bad for my mental and physical health.”
Indeed, people in “larger bodies” often experience more anxiety, depression, and stress, but it is critical to ask why. Research shows these mental health outcomes are often driven by weight stigma, not body size itself (Tomiyama, 2014).
Body Image Essential Reads
When someone is constantly exposed to teasing, discrimination, or medical bias, it is no wonder they might struggle with self-worth, social anxiety, and even trauma symptoms. This stigma also discourages people from seeking mental health care, fearing judgment from providers.
By challenging these biases, both in society and in ourselves, we can create space for emotional well-being at any size.
5. “Focusing on weight loss is the best way to take care of my health.”
Health is far more complex than a number on the scale. However, when “health” becomes synonymous with weight loss, people often develop obsessive, perfectionistic patterns that harm their mental health, like rigid food rules, compulsive exercise, or deep guilt when they cannot meet unrealistic goals.
In contrast, research shows that adopting behaviors such as eating regularly (having consistent meals and snacks throughout the day to nourish the body), moving in ways that feel good, and practicing stress management, even without weight loss, can improve both physical and mental health outcomes (Tylka et al., 2014).
Shifting the focus from shrinking your body to supporting your emotional well-being can be liberating and often leads to better long-term mental health.
The Bottom Line
The idea that weight loss is the key to happiness and health is deeply ingrained in our culture, but it does not hold up to the evidence. If you are struggling with your relationship to food, your body, or your mental health, know that you do not have to punish or shrink yourself to deserve care and respect.
Healing is possible, and it does not start with a diet.