Why Peloton’s Wall Street Upgrade Is a Trap for Investors

view original post

A Meme-Fueled Surge with Shaky Foundations

Peloton Interactive (NASDAQ:PTON) has been a rollercoaster for investors, with the ride mostly consisting of stomach-churning plunges. However, its stock is soaring 198% from its 52-week low, including a 10.3% spike in a single day on August 8, driven by bullish analyst coverage. Shares are up another 5.6% in morning trading today. 

Going for just 10 times free cash flow, the connected fitness company appears dirt cheap, especially after Goldman Sachs upgraded it from neutral to buy, raising its price target from $7 to $11.50 per share, implying 61.7% upside from the time of the call. 

However, this rally masks deeper issues. Peloton’s stock has been battered since its pandemic peak, down 90% from its 2021 highs, due to persistent customer churn and a failure to monetize its 6 million members effectively. 

While Wall Street is celebrating recent cost-cutting and a surprise profit, this surge is not a genuine turnaround. Instead, it is a fleeting, meme-driven bounce that is likely to disappoint investors again.

Goldman’s Upgrade Sparks a Rally

Peloton’s stock surged after Goldman Sachs issued its bullish note and upgraded the stock to buy. The upgrade followed Peloton’s fiscal fourth-quarter results, which showed a surprise profit of $0.05 per share, defying Wall Street’s expected $0.05 loss. Cost-cutting initiatives have significantly improved margins, with equipment gross margins doubling to 17.6% and subscription margins rising to 72%. 

These gains, coupled with $200 million in projected 2026 free cash flow, fueled investor optimism. Goldman highlighted stabilizing sales trends and potential for enterprise customer growth, suggesting Peloton’s turnaround is gaining traction. 

The stock’s low valuation, at less than 7 times 2026 EBITDA estimates, further amplified the bullish sentiment, driving the stock’s big gain.

Cost-Cutting and Margin Gains Mask Underlying Weakness

Peloton’s recent financials show progress in streamlining operations. The company’s focus on cost discipline has quadrupled free cash flow, with subscriptions now comprising two-thirds of revenue at higher margins. 

Management’s guidance for 2026 projects a 9% revenue decline at the midpoint of its range, hinting the hoped-for return to growth is not happening anytime soon. However, international expansion is on the horizon, which could bolster sales if U.S. operations stabilize. 

Yet these improvements obscure a critical issue: Peloton’s connected fitness subscriptions still face a 6% churn rate, and the company has not demonstrated a sustainable model for monetizing its declining 2.8 million paid subscribers. 

High stock-based compensation, equating to 10% of its $2.8 billion market cap, further erodes shareholder value, signaling that profitability may remain elusive despite short-term gains. Peloton also said it was gutting 6% of its global workforce as part of its broader cost-cutting measures. A company can only cut so much before it starts to impact core operations, and PTON may have already realized all the gains possible from these measures.

Key Takeaways

Despite the recent rally and Wall Street’s enthusiasm, Peloton Interactive remains a risky bet. The company’s stock price, while up significantly, is driven by speculative momentum rather than a proven business model. 

Peloton has struggled to convert its 6 million members into a reliable revenue stream, with ongoing subscriber churn undermining growth prospects. Moreover, those 6 million members are down from 6.1 million in Q3 and 6.4 million a year ago. Paid connected fitness subscribers are also down sequentially and year-over-year. Beyond churn, it is having trouble attracting new members to its platform. Peloton is not a growth business.

The connected fitness guru’s turnaround hinges on unproven assumptions about user retention and profitability. Its high stock-based compensation and lack of a clear monetization strategy for connected fitness users suggest this is a short-term bounce, not a sustainable recovery. 

Investors chasing this rally risk disappointment as Peloton’s fundamentals remain shaky. Its business is at best a niche one, and not a trend, and PTON stock could revert to its downward trajectory, leaving latecomers with losses.

Thank you for reading! Have some feedback for us?
Contact the 24/7 Wall St. editorial team.