Makhana vs peanuts — one is light, the other fills you up. Which snack wins for weight loss? The smarter choice may depend on when you eat. (Pic credit: Pinterest)
Snacking has long been painted as the villain of weight loss — the quiet saboteur between lunch and dinner. Yet nutritionists increasingly say that the problem isn’t snacking itself, but what and how much we eat.
With packed schedules, unpredictable mealtimes and long workdays, most people naturally reach for quick energy between meals. And in many Indian homes, the choice often comes down to two familiar bowls on the kitchen counter: makhana and peanuts.
Both have loyal followers. One is airy and light enough to mindlessly munch through a movie. The other is hearty, satisfying and hard to stop at just a handful. But when the goal is weight loss, which one wins?
Also Read: Kidney stones, blood sugar and allergy patients should avoid makhana, here’s why
Makhana: The gentle light-weight
Roasted fox nuts have quietly become a favourite of fitness-focused households. Low in calories and fat, makhana delivers volume without overload — a small cup can feel plentiful, making it a popular evening snack.
Its appeal goes beyond calories. Makhana is easy to digest, doesn’t sit heavy on the stomach and offers a mild carbohydrate boost for energy. But there’s a limitation baked in: it’s low in protein and fat, which means the fullness fades fast.
A snack for when you want something crunchy and light — not one designed to carry you through a long evening.
Peanuts: Compact, filling and calorie-dense
Peanuts take a different route. Rich in protein, fibre and healthy fats, they are one of the most satiating foods you can snack on without turning to packaged protein bars. Just a small handful can keep hunger at bay for hours.
But the same nutrients that keep you full also pack more calories per bite. A few extra spoons — especially fried or masala-coated peanuts — can quickly tip the day’s balance. With peanuts, portion control is the difference between a smart snack and accidental overeating.
A quick nutrition contrast (per 30 g)
Makhana
- ~100 calories
- ~3 g protein
- ~0.5 g fat
Peanuts
- ~170 calories
- ~7 g protein
- ~14 g fat
The real answer: it depends what you need
There’s no single winner — only a better choice for the moment.
- Need something light? Makhana.
- Need to stay full longer? Peanuts.
- Trying to strike the middle ground? Pair a small serving of peanuts with makhana or seeds.
Also Read: Best healthy snacks: Beat hunger cravings by eating smart, mindful munching
Roasting at home — and avoiding oil-heavy, sugar-dusted or salt-loaded packets — makes both options healthier.
In the end, makhana and peanuts are more than convenient fillers — they’re proof that simple foods can do the job well when used wisely. Weight loss isn’t about cutting snacks out, but choosing the ones that work for your appetite instead of against it.
FAQs on benefits of makhana and peanuts as snacks
1. What are the benefits of snacking on makhana?
Makhana is low in calories and fat, making it a good choice for those looking for a light snack. It is easy to digest, doesn’t sit heavy on the stomach, and provides a mild carbohydrate boost for energy.
2. Why are peanuts considered a good snack?
Peanuts are rich in protein, fibre, and healthy fats, making them one of the most satiating snacks. They can keep hunger at bay for hours and are a nutritious alternative to packaged protein bars.
3. How can I make my makhana and peanut snacks healthier?
Roasting makhana and peanuts at home instead of purchasing oil-heavy, sugar-dusted, or salt-loaded packets can make both options healthier. This way, you control the ingredients and avoid unnecessary additives.